ATAS/19/2008
Décisions | Chambre des assurances sociales de la Cour de justice Cour de droit public
15 janvier 2008Français16 min
Source ge.ch
!"# $$%! !$ &' (&!&' % $&(% ( '% ()* !"# $ %!&' ("' !)"' *' + ' ' ++ ) $$ , -./ '!" -- 1 of 12 - 012340433/,4024, %& +!
Considérants
25.
6,&78'9'(":'" ''- ( )'& )'; 2..2 # "!; 2../5 $ "'' <).=35,>5;'&? <3?&!5
45.
' 1 &'!; 2..@ ' "&" &7 )++ ) $$ , A6,&78 9 ! &'' ),( '">! )'(:'>> )! "?:' )?-&''"5
15.
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of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
235.
( F "!; 433< $ A A 6,&78$9!'':)&'" '(#233E"'' LC; '('"N'&'H"('C>>'&?-: ' !L # : !&'' )>' 6L5 "C'9H5 ! );('&>&''5
225.
&&' " &'' &> F "!; 433= ) L&': )'' !D!G('"'"L&:"': !& C&!''' ''L )( '" 2<F@E '& '#'5'''&&; '(# 233E!D! '('" &'"'('!'":)&"'"'' &"( ! 433F )? C5 ) &&' :' # ( !" '''5 & '!' # )( !" $ ) &':)! );(' &>&('G'>H> )"((&':&'" '(" " )"H5 -- 3 of 12 - 012340433/,<024,
245.
&&'!" '!" 2 >"( 433F >!'&" )?CC?:)"''CC("433=5 )"'' C"" "'' '; & C>> " ' )?-&' "'' >> # 'B5!" '''"'"':&'" '( '"'' =3E '('"!&''?C&?-:5& '(# 'L &(' D' (C" &7 ? C C? &"( &?!' L % '?' ! &7 ' # !5 ' ' (!;;!' ! ( 'C );(' &>#!!'5
215.
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of 12 - 012340433/,=024, 2@5 " 2= G 433/ ) &&!" ' ' 7 &! G L7!! (' '>' " ' &":) C"' ")'& )>>'&>6'5FF './ $95 $ ! L& '!'(" ' &(' ''>;""> ( &!' ) 5 ;' ) '!': !' "( '#' "!'':)"'' '" ')"'';!'!""'433F ' &; & ) '('" &> &'" # & '!& ' ; !'5 &7(&" "#!& () ''':'L )( '""'' 2</3E; ):D' '' 433<6,&78$$433<9'; 2''?!! (<'==)33=F>5&5 !''('"'"!&"( "'":'&('"( '"!!''-' F<)=4.>5/35 C" )( '"' (''*&& '# '5
2.5
'' &'" . O' 433/ ' >!" ; ":) >!'' " 2=G433/5";!''' " & !&"' :) L&'!" G 5 &!''#)' )H' )( '"'7&' >' &'" '( " !" !' "';H ( ' >' "&5
435.
!"! !&"!' 4.&'!;433/' ! ! &( ''' )>>' &> ' H (!' ) ' )( '" /=EG:)# 'GC"> H5&":&";!' 'HL&'!" &?-&'CH5!'' &&5 ;' L&:) >> )?-&' "(7 : H&;7! '" '(!' C(H & '&''"5&'''#(''!'!" !'L : !"'!!':)#!''#HL! " "CH !&:' &"7(!' ' " ' &(' '* >' 6!! (!; 433<9 '" '"5 ' &? L!" $ & ( ' !&' : &"7 ' )( & H:' C!' !7 '' ">":: L '"" '!" LH5''!:)- ''H &!'!& ' # '' &(H:) &' L '('" &'":)# =3E : &''L )( '"#F<F@E6=3EP2<F@E9(' '#',:' '5)L&'!" )?-&'C&!'' "'! :! "'' '" H' !&'; ( )L )::'('"&>H5 -- 5 of 12 - 012340433/,F024, ( !"! !&"!' ' & ' ( !'!" L ' '''' 2< O' 433/ !'':) G' ); >' ": & '" ' >>!' 'B;!C" ''?"& ':) H>> "C!' ) "'' L, "&> # ' &;7! >!LH5 !" '! &'" '( ' # =3E & '( "'' & )>>' &?-: !&''5
425.
4<';433/'>'&( ;&&' )?&'' F';433/ % '"':)>'"' C:#!" !':)& "'!:5
445.
"& 12 '; 433/ ) ' G' ' # >!' "'':"5;')"'' '" ')' !"" & " / (!; 4332 ': ' &!''' "( ' # ' ' !&5 )''' G'>' ))&'" '' & &' '> # '&'' " "'':>" )L'5)?-&''":L' ) &2.@@: ' '(' !! ''- )' & &'; > &'" '( C " '('""C75&'" '( "''#(''' 'D'&&!">!"!'L'5@@52 '@@;54 5
415.
2.(!;433/&''"'">!":"'' C "#GC5 %& $!
25.
>!"!' # )'5 =F 5 2 '5 ?5 4 C( )C' G 69 ; ' *' ' : ''' &"( # Q' =F >" " &' C"" ' F '; 4333 6 9: ' '(#>" "Q,( '" 2.G2.=.6 95 $!&"'&GC Q&7'"';5
45.
' &&; )&7 7 : >' G :!' "'!' ) "(' "( ' ' "" &'"!'#'"(C2G(43316>5 +213<<F 5 2 24. < 5 25495 '' "'' ! >' "C ' '''7CC""(>!" G& '(L'& '(')'"(C R ) " ! >' &' ( ' ': G& "(&&" # && &' D' & ' &&:"
6.
+2131<= 5195
-- 6 of 12 --
012340433/,/024,
15.
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of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of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of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of 12 - 012340433/,22024, >!"!' && G& ' : " '!'' # ';' &'" " '(5 $ )'!" ( "5 ! &> (' # & ' '' " '' !&' !'' >' !&'' ' &!" 5.5 ! N " '':" ' " ! ''' )>>'&> (';G'5
235.
':;''&'!'C '# "&>L" )&7#2)=33>56'5F2'5C 95>" " 2F "!; 433=! >' >" " ),( '" '" (C 2 G' 433F 6433F 43319 &&'" ! >': ' '!!' &" ' (' ; ' 6'5=4=@'F2'5 95&'&" !'7 '''&'')'> &'' ) (' ; "' "!!# > G': ('''433 >5'2)333>56'5F.52; 95 &"' '!( ' 6?5'5 &''''(#! >' 2F "!; 433=95) 'C"!!' 133>5!#?C )'!"5 -- 11 of 12 - 012340433/,24024, $ (%,! + '%!$ &' (&!&' % $&(% ( '% -.*
25.
"(;5 -.
45.
)!'&'!'' " ) 2=G433/5
15.
( # )'!" & !&"!' )'' "''( "5 <5 '"!!' 133>5#?C )'!"5 =5 !Q'!"#('!! 2)=33>5#'' "&5 F5 >! &' :Q &(' >! ' &"' D' " 13 G 7 '>' &7 ; >" " 6$?XY?>:FF33< 9&( !'7 ' &;>!"!'L'5@4 >" " ;>" " 2/ G 433= 6 +9R !"! ' : !'> '!- &('&'C' ' ! 'R ' D' " ; >" " & ( &' & ( "': L ' )'5 <4 +5 &"' D' ' &7 & '(:"!!!- &( ('D'G'#)(5 C>>7 &" ' ;$ "',G'8 ( &>! &"'D'''>"L&':Q#Q>>>" " &C>> -- 12 of 12 --