Décisions | Chambre des assurances sociales de la Cour de justice Cour de droit public

18.

!$($)(#"'"('9"' 133: "( ( ( $($ ' 0; ' * * <&'= >8

58.

14?133@!'"("$#(;"*'")A!()" '9""*'"""B%(C*("$(0$(((#A$"8 $($A$';(;0($($'$$'!'$(. 0;(0;"#!13?133@!'/"#"( ';0D '( " ;#( "&' "B $;#( $($ '(E$"((#F#()(8:8 ''$("59$)5666! !'$(. 0; ( ##A " *$E' " #$" " "( " ! *( $($"9(E*'(;#(($($$$(?'=*"( ( "E$ ' ') $(A " #= $ " ($ ( &(*"("13?133@8 G8 1H # 5661! '$"$ % "B=# ()( 0;!%)(0"="';(;0#/"*'E ((8

78.

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of 11 - 234125667 &:211&

48.

" " *$ $($ "$ 9 E* "$(#E(")"B()(((( ;) 9! #" B("! ) ((( ((BE'*('*(("8 $;"!&*( '$"("1:#566:"#=)(JK"B()( ( #'$0A8 ! 'A=# $" E#( " *"( <"$>"()(!("#""*B$(8#'(& " '$( B(F##( ( '#((( ' " "$" ";) 9!"#"!)"*(((((K8*''+('' E(0'$"$'$(0A(*$((" (""'$((8 H8 "$"1#566G!*&"(9$"'"0; '$(#($E$E8 @8 ""''(!*$)$E*"('$(*$(( '?(9$!)B)(E*(0"=)($($B$($)(" =; " *(! "( "( #'A ( ')E( "#( " 'E8 (#( ' $E( E *'$( " 1H # 5661 ")( F( "$$ ## "( ( (( ' " *(( " "?E*% "( E *B'( B(?".E*("(#((L)8

38.

!'"$''("G?)5667!9#$E**B(( "($("(($("14?133@!"* '(!(()(0;"13?133@(1H#5661"*('(! ( $ E & '( (( "( " ( " ?'"8

168.

" 7 ) 5667! *$ (( 9 " *&"( " "$E*#$"()"*()(0;"1H #5661'F("$$##"(" 8($ ' " '$"?E*% "( " " "* '$" "*B'( E* ($ '= " . ' "$(# E ( $($ #'(A #$" ((( E *'$( '$($ "'E'"*;"';(8"=E * ' ; =; " *( ( ## ;) " ((#(8 *(0"=!E$((#((&"E$!;;)$((("( %#'(()"($8=)E!#$"&" !99#$E*/)(#$"!%)((#((& "E$(E&$((%*;""##;A8

118.

$("4#5667!*(#$=)E*(0"=!##"* '( ;#( " ';(;0 99($ 13? 133@! (( "

-- 3 of 11 --

234125667 &G211& 0B (0$'(E #'$0A! "B ()( ( "$$ E* /("*"((#(""*;)9!"* #" "* ((( (( ( E *"( " "B '$( $(( (E$8 *"( "* ()( 0; *( ' (=?"E#('(('?;(#$""$(#$$'"% "$9($;"*"(8'$E(?("8

158.

$'E"5G?5667!*$'("$;$" ('$E!"''$(":#566:!"E( E 0; *)( ' ; ; ( ( )( ## ;) " ((#(8"=E*()("1H#5661"(F(E9$"*( #$" *$(( "$A#( " '(E ( #$" ( (('$E("(8 1:8 " 5H?( 5667! *(#$ *'' % "#" " ' "*((#(E*B'(.*''(%("(;E '(E#(E(")*()(0;A' (1H#5661(("(!E(%E'(F( $'"E'$;()8 1G8 F("("5:I(5667! A"$"#(EF()(% '"*((""*((("*B'(.8

178.

"( " 5G?) 566H! ( ) % '$" *B'( B(?" " . #"! E* ("( A " '; ('E " &8 ! ( " (( "= E "B #$"("(%(((8=)A(E*"( ((''#=()("13?133@E'""17# 5661!$(($!E'$(*)('"?(9((9E( E* * ' $($ 9#$ (#( " (( '$'$(8 ( *B'(E'$K9(E*$%B(("(;(% ''( " '"! E * 99()#( #$ E*% (0"= <"#("'9'($>(A"K8'!9B("( "'E"(F("$;$##K0;#(#0K"B ) *)( ''##( ' "*'' 9B ( $ % (" (=#)E#=*B'(%EK'$"$"("(B( F( "$;$ ## ( B =; " *(K8 ( ( E *B'( . "$#( "( 'A E "B;) #$" ("(%)"($8

148.

"$(#( " 5: # 566H! *(#$ =) E! *''$( "15#566H"!"B'$(BE)('$"$ *$(( "(A#( " '(E ( #$"8 ( $( "( ((9 F( ((0$ % *A "*"( ' -- 4 of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

18.

9#$#( % *(8 74 8 1 (8 08 7 " ;) *;(?" <>! A ( " +( ( E " ((( '$) % M( 74 " 9$"$ '(;$$ " "( " " 4 (A 5666 < > E ( ()%9$"$M&"("56#13@1< >8 #'$('?;""M'=($(A8

58.

( ($ ); 1?) 566: (+( #"9( " #A "'( " "# " 8 ?'"! $;( ''A " 0;#( " =; " "( ( E $(( ); " $( " *$(( " 9( E "( F( ''$$?"E#( E " $E?"E < 15H G4H "81!154144"8GA>!9(E A"$'(F( #$ % ' " " "* '$" " $(( ' BE('"(?E*##(""$"#(()(; -- 5 of 11 - 234125667 &4211& < 151:44"81A>8#N9(%*;"'$(( "(#((%133@(5661!"*'=($;'$;( );?E*:1"$#A56658)0!=;"'$"( ''A8:8 *(8 164 & ''A?E*:1 "$#A 5664 &! "$;( % *(8 46 ! "$ " ( " ( # ' "$ ''( '(( '(( "*8 ! (?($ " 9#("$'('!()A8 G8 (;'(E(")(((A"()( 0;99($13?133@(1H#5661(((""( "( I( ( $E ")( F( ' 0; ' *& "(8

78.

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of 11 - 234125667 &H211& "*"(< 'A$"51(A566:!4526:"8:85D 'A$"1@?(566:!74261"858:D 151:7"81AD 11@ 73"85AD 11@5@:"85A>8 E( " *B( "* "(! " "( " *&"( A;(!"(F((0$"$'"##("'(")*9(B =;"*("($'"#$"(+'A($<)""( 'A>8 ) " #F# % *$;" "*?;#( '$ $)( (( #'(#("#$"< 'A$"51(A566:!4526:"8:85D 151:@"81AD 11@5@:"85A($9$>8 '(#A5666! A9$"$"B'(#(9#$?'" E OMB; "M ( #$" M$(( "$A#( " '(E #$" (P '$(( M " "( $ ' "#(( MB( "M "(D #( ?($0;#("?'"!E("(%"$((9( " #$" ## $)$#( B(" < 5666 Q G6H '8 G6G! G64R "55'(#A5666!557233"83A>8

48.

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of 11 - 234125667 &@211& 33>8*B("*"($;#($($$""*((('( " 'B A0;0! ;;)$ ' ;"/('0! "* '$(((%$("*B($#($($"*S(< 'A$"51(A566:!452566:"8:8:>("""$="( "* 0 '0/(E $(( " *0( " (#"! "$$ ## ((#( E *$(( ' " '(E ( *$(( " #$" % *$'E < 'A$ " 15 ) 5664!

7.

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of 11 - 234125667 &3211& #/"')8)("''$$'?'"( M''$("')!?;(((9("MB#(''% #(("(!'((;B#'((!M'(" MB'(#"($'(A8 ((?'"M''EAEM $("#((!#/"MB'(')$! "MB'(#$;$'M&"('99 < 157:71D "53(A566:!:5126:"8:81>8

38.

*! ( '"( B'( B(?" " .! 99($ ' ! '$( 0; (0'$"E ( '( 0; " #! ( ' ! '$( 0; ( 0; " #! #';$ "* ("( A " '; ('E8 #$" '$($ ( '$"$ % B# E " (((("(E($8($;#($("$ #AB ''( #$"B ( 0$ ";E8 B'( ( #'=((A#()$8 /'$E("+(' )'A(!E*(#$(("*'8

168.

'$A!)("'$E"*"('$()$ (("*B'(E"*''$("(' &#F#!')(F('"$("# N! ?'" " A 9$"$! " ( ( '?"E#( '(( '?; *( #$" (( "(8

118.

( "= % B# '$( #$ $'"( % *B; " (= B("! B; E & ''& & "( F( "# E " #= $)=! ( ((( ' $E( 9( B($ B(" "(!$0$(!%*"#"*B("*"(8 >'$(E(%!"''$("1:#566:! E ()( $(( #'$0A! # )( E #'( "'$(B(F##(('#((('""$"";) 9 #"! E ( 0 " '$"$ '$( ")( F( "$$ ## #'=(#( 0A( *$(( "$A#("(""'$((8 A> *;( " *'$( " 13? 133@! B'( ##$ ( % " ";( E "( #( % "( '$( $ # $;#( % " ((#(! % ) *B$( "* '$( E *$(( ' '' % ; 99 " (8 ( "$$ $;#( E* #E( $(/; (9E ( E ") " ";"(('$'$()($($)$8 (*()( " 1H # 5661! #$" #"($ ' . ( (($ E *''0 -- 9 of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

158.

')"*#$""(*/('$($''($";$" )#A'$'"$(B;$'?'"< 15156@"8 4A>!"(F(?($8

-- 10 of 11 --

234125667 &11211& 5-04 -0 - 0 % 6 2

18.

$)A8 % 6

58.

?((8:8 (E'$"(;((8 G8 9# '( " EM ')( 9# ( '$( F( " "$ ":6? "= (9( '= " A 9$"$ < 0WX09E4!466G >!')"#(=""( 'A!9#$#(B(8@5"9$"$ A9$"$"1H? 5667 < >D #$# " "( "E ! #(9 ( #/"')('(;("("#"(D"( F( "$ A 9$"$ ' ) '( ' ) $(E B "( " *(8 G5 8 '$( F( ( '= ' " (!)E$###/"')!")(F(?(%*)8 ;99= & , $"( - ;99=&?(J (0 '9#"'$(F(((9$B'(EM%M999$"$ "($'AE';99 -- 11 of 11 --

Considérants

18.

58.

78.

48.

38.

168.

118.

158.

178.

148.

18.

58.

78.

48.

7.

38.

168.

118.

158.

18.

58.