ATAS/33/2008
Décisions | Chambre des assurances sociales de la Cour de justice Cour de droit public
15 janvier 2008Français26 min
Source ge.ch
! " ! # $% % &'()*&(++, -&))&(++. -/ - / 01" ' % '2 3 (++. !" #$%&'!& (!&)&% *+, % %%& &% -- (.. , % /01 & ! -- 1 of 15 - 2345624771,4238, 4/-
Considérants
39.
. $ 3011 '%:% ;< #. !&! ' & ( &46=' %4778>;&%'%?@" &A BB%& ( B%&% ( !; %% BB %&&% (!$?; & ! $ ?;9 !&! $% ;%? $% . =A(57= 477C9
49.
36 'D% 4778 (%! !$! $%: (-- (.. , >,$%: @' &"$% ;%? ( % && $%B %& ' $%B $&&"(&% (%&( ' &!9
59.
%$$%& 35 !D% 4778 % $! & -* %; %%? $! ?& $&; 8,.3$%&% '!&&$%! ! A( (' &'(%!A(B $%' %; %%? 9
69.
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
19.
%$$%&3C=' %477C%?!!% &B %! ?& B%&%,&&34!; %% BB%&&% (!$ % & & &% ;' ?; '% $ 46 =' %
-- 2 of 15 --
2345624771,5238, 4778 & =&! " & &% ?& %!$% % $ &! &%' '%& &?I ! & ?;%%&, G&& & (&!$% $ '% 4778 & $&$& $/$& & &%D & $ 31 $&D% 30009 & ! ( $ &! &%' " 377E $ 46 =' % 47789 % $%! ! A (!&&&!!& &&& %&$&H&(! %& 9. (%!$&$G%%(& ' &!&!% %%';&%& ' &! &$ D$%&&A( &!& %&$%&;%?9$%! B%& D %$%G$9 J9 38 477C. B%!(%! A(&& &B $ & ! G&( &!=%:%57= 477C !%& $ & $& &%' : = & 477C &!&& $%! ! A &%D D %" $&; 8,.3(!& &$";%?9
09.
&%%?!$%& %(%!% A!43= & 477C A $ &! &%' $& & ?& % &F (;%?% !& & 87E A( $' & K&% $& && & ' &! $&!$%& $%&;%?% &%' $ & D&$%?!9
379.
' 43L&477C% .%' ! %!? >,$%:.@ ??!%! % " . " =% %, & & ( &%%?% ($/% B A( B% % $& B $%! % % $& &%' ! $% (%! >$ D &! (&%% $ & 2D&$%&;%?G @9
339.
#. $%!!34&D%477C"& '%&M; A '&K&%!$&&%' (%! % &:%N O$&&OO!?%2$OO/OO $%&&ON, BB%& $;/ A A &M; %!$!& & ' & " ;' &% G % &:% &O!?%2$O&O/O, (/ $ &%'G $%! (;% % %%!? % & $ (' %&'D% &2$:%2B% &$'/?P (? &$ $($&"%$D &!! $%, BB%& &&&%' D&& &!&!%?!O/O, !$&&B%& $%B 2 %O!?%2$O9
349.
J'D%477C% $% &A%9 $! &-*; %%? ! (%% &. ' &
-- 3 of 15 --
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of 15 - 2345624771,8238, $%D:D %L" $&; 8,.3/$&& A&&(& $";%?(%, &O9 % $% !%& && B& '&N $$%&;%?$38F?$$ & &%&$%&,", BG $ BG %&& %!$!&! &% $ D &! (&%% $ & &D&;A;%9 "$ &!&%' G? D 377E (& ' &! &!% % : 3% = & 477C A& A !& & & &O. O9
359.
( A!"(%!37'D%477C$%=&! G &%A% &"%&&:%( ' &! !& &%46=' % 57= 477C(?& $:&&% . 9 ( $% % B%! (%!!?& 37 'D% 477C $%=&%B%%$%B 9
369.
(%! %$%!&! $% )&% % *+, B & %%A% " ( $%%% %41'D%477CA. ' &!% &" $%&& ," = & 477C % (D &! &%&%( &%!&&%DD %/$&& A&&! > $&; 8,.3@9%&%D&&&!( &$%'& $ &'(%, & '&$%&%K&%$% !%& $ &'( :%A( & B%& %$ &! &%' &? 9 $ &!&%' $&,K&%& !"87E $%B & " 377E ' %& &! & ' &! $&!/&%&$%B >B9%$$%&% 43= &477C@9
389.
' &! " !&% % % &%%?! 3C =' % 4771 % &. % $ & ' % N OA & $ &! &%' G? D& ' &!A ! &% &$$ & &%& $%&,",BG $ BG %!$!&! &% $ D &! (&%% $ & &D&;A;%&$%&;%? &!"8F?';% % %!? % =% ' %& D% D% & $:% & B% !$& ,;% &%' '/? " (!&%?% &('!; &D O9 3C9 % ! 45 B!'% % 4771 ( ! " (%! %& &:% ( ' &!3%=' %57= 477C9
319.
&8%4771% B &!&&%!$% &%'36B!'% %4771A% $& $& &%' !&D $% #. D %%$% G $ &!
-- 5 of 15 --
2345624771,C238, $& &9 % & A $ &! &%' (%! & %&! ;?!$ %$$%&.J'D%477C9 3J9 ! 45 B!'% % 4771 /&!&! & B! $% &?' $& & / % & & ' % &&%!$%&!&!!&%$!$%G '! K&%34%&44%47719
309.
(%!$%( &%! %& % &%=&!%%30'% 4771 &% ! 44 % > R 23C3724771@ & 4C % &% ! 34%4771> R 2345624771@9 $%!D&%A $ ( &%& $%!%%& '" (&% %& =A(" % & =?! %& ' %B % %!$&& =A("G!& %:%9 ( $%& & $% $& " $% ;%? % %!$&& $%B & D %& %' " ( $% $!& ( &%& ! & ' ! " A( G$%& & %! ' & "!'% $ &! &%' %:% & ' &! $%B G%! A % ( & ' &! $&! & (&%$%&"(&% (%&&:%,"57= 477C9
479.
G$%!' 38&43L&4771( $%$!%=&%%9
439.
%%% %6$&D%4771 23C3724771(%! &$ $%% & ( $& !%% A( & &&& $D (G%%& ' &!%& ';D &;<#. =A(57= 477C $ % % %!$&& & B & !&& &! =% A( & $& " %$%% && K & ' &! " 377E9%:'$% %A(' %36B!'% %4771% AB( & 43= &477C&&% & %9
449.
45'D%4771 % D!%!=& G9
459.
& &!&!?%!"=?%9 /-
39.
B%!& " (%&9 8C 9 3 &9 ;9 4 ?' % (%? & = % >@ % D & % )& & A &&& $%!' " S%& 8C B!!% % $%&
-- 6 of 15 --
2345624771,1238,?!!% % & % C &D% 4777 > @ A & %& '" B!!%%S%, ' &!30= 3080> @9.$!&$%=?%S$:& !&D 9 49 & &%! '?% 3% =' % 4775 &%)& B & !? & ' && % & (%, ' &!9 $ & ' &$%&$% $$$ D%:?% &'?%&T B & =% A& !&% & & $% & & =? % B$% $$%$$%! %%(!&&B &%! !" &!&% &! %$$ & &? > -3406 9394P 3C0 93P58C 93&%%K& &!@9A %$%!%& "!B&%:?&% & %&% % &%($$ & ($$ A& %!%' : =% % &%! '?% > - 331 05 9CDP3345C7 96P 300JU51$953C 95D@9.% B % D ! %:' A ! &? /&!&! %&34&44%4771&&&&%!&&B &=% A& !&% & %&& " (! 4778 $%!& &? % G ! " :% $ & 9 ' & A A( & %'% A $ & (& $ B! & ( ' &! ( & =% $% - /%& '&&=%(& &!9
59.
!$!B%&! $%!'$% %%&%'D>%&9 C7 @9
69.
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of 15 - 2345624771,J238, $%& %N%X &% %&<?%&%' %' '% ;%?&;:-% D%?4774$9355@9%!?&& % %!' % &BB&& &%B&=% A"%!G & % & " %& >B %BY??$? '%B;%%;& ; %B?% & ; ' ' %&%' N.;BB;%2.;% V*%?W ' ' % &? %.< '% ;%?. &,3000$938@9 (& (%&!?% '&$% %& B & % & > & $$% %&@ & K&% B G! B%!& " (%&9 JJ 9 3 > - 348 631 9 4 P 30J6 $9 351@9. && $ & &%'?%:3%=' %4776 $ &!? $ &! ($ % &%'G;D & ( %! (! % A $&(&&! / !%%A ;?&$$% !;!&&&$%& % &G$%&& :A($&(&&%" A(! %& &&! & %&<?$!% 9' K %A( & ;?& !&% & %! &% !=" &%%$& &D&A($ & $%; &"% %9
89.
G &% (%&9 J 9 3 & 5 ( ' &! & !B !&& ( $ &! ? && $%& A & $%!! $%& ? %!9 %! =% A SG%Z & $ S& ' &! %& ' '& SK&% && &%&!$;/ A&&& $&K&%G?!AS G%& & %!$&! ' S&& & $K; S$ % % &%'G;D &9. S%&9 6 ( ' &! $& %!&% ( B % &! ?! &( ( &9 S ' &!&%!$&!%': AS&$%&%&?%' &!$%$%"'% %% &G$%&& &%& !%& 9 & %!$&! $ &! &%' && $%& && $%& S$& & S%!"$ %$%B S& ' &!&%' A $& K&%% D&K&%G?! &&$%&%!&&!$;/ A &9 S $ &! &%' ? %! S& ' &! A $& K&% G?! $& %'% S &% $%B S &% S& ' &! >%&9 C @9 & %!$&! $ &! ? && & SD S $%& $ D &! ? S%! % %;! &%' !A D%!A &% !%& && & %!&S&& & " &! $;/ A & & AS $% & $%: &% && & %%!$&& G? D>%&91 @9. =% $% & ( ' &! % & % & & ! A & ! P & !A! A D=& ' ( $ &! B& A( $%& (!'% > - 337 418 9 6 378 471 9 4@9 %A( % ( & ' &! -- 8 of 15 - 2345624771,0238, (%! !! A B& !B& / B% % !(%%! %T$%&&&(!'%$ &! &%' ( &!%!& ' &!% D&G? D> -338355 9437838J 93P - $D!30'% 4774886273@9 C9. (%&9 4J 9 3 &% '?% =A( 53 !D% 4775 (%!% &"%&&:%( & ' "CC425E ", %&( & ' "87E "A%&%&( & ' "67E P $! D (%! $& ($%: (%&9 4J 9 3D $%!&%",%&( & ' "67E 9(&%!'?% 3%=' %47766:%!' B!&%(%&94J93 %& B " (!;& %& &G ( ' &!9 % A( %& &:%!& & %! $%'& " %! : A ?%! ( ' &! &&? &CC425E&& $ & $%!' &!% (&%/%&% ,A%& %& " %! $%!&& ?%! ( ' &! ( C7E & %& &:% " & &G & $!% % " 17E & %& ' " (&% ( A%& ( ,%& %& ;?!9 %'; $% $ !'$$! =A(% $% =% $% &:% (!'& ( ' &! %'&%' &!A &($ % 6:%!' > -35756J 9596P - $D!31 47781278 94C$&D%4776460276 96@9
19.
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of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
09.
A %'%$%D&(%$$%&! A &!&% & (& A $ & &? G & B & (D=& (!& %&! A
-- 10 of 15 --
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
379.
B%!&"(%&9J93 %! ' !( ' &! &&% &G%%!$&& A &! %&&%" %!&D % % $ &! ? " (! %% " '?%% " B'% % (?% &!&&!&% !B& &&%!(& ' &!$%DD9.(%&931 (%!% &%&'$%B ' &! % && % ! % & A $ &! ? $& && '% D K&% '?%! ! %! >9 3@9 %!!& -- 11 of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of 15 - 2345624771,35238, &! G! % ($ &'! (%!&$& "%!$&& & B %(%%$%B &%&? $& ( & G % %:&& $ D &! %!$&& $%B & B % $% B % & (G %' %!$&& $%B " &% (D%'& $%B $% G$9. $%A $%:"(G& A(%!$&& (&$ $ D & $%! % & B & D=& B & %&9. %% ' " A % (%% $%B & A! & !&%% %&:% $$%$%! % $& D &! ' $& & &; $ (%! & $ D &! %! & %!$&& & ? A($&$&%>B9; BB%4707"4375@9
339.
($: ( B& % . A (%! $' & G%% $%B &!% % ?& % &F ( &% ;%?:%"$ &$$ 3%= &477C($%&%B! $% ;%? % %!$&& $%B & (&% $%& ( %% &(%!"%&&:%( ' &!A46=' %57 = 477C9
349.
/&&B (D%'%A. B "$%&& 57= 477C$%A( !%!%D%$$%&%&! 33 477C A (%! $%!& & $ ( $ &! &%' && A?& %&F(;%?% $%!A &" ' %&%;' ?;& (!$% &B%&%% &!%,$!% %34,"&&&9 %( ($"$%!$%(G &( &!&%( & &&%D&BB%%(%! ( % &:%&&%%!B!%%G . 9 359.% &(%!$%% &G%% & ' &! !?:% &/$ &%' D% ' & %& % 47E9 $%! & &&B % %!$&& $%B 9 / %$$%"&!?%A&%$'&K&%' ?! A &G ( ' &! B%& $%B $$!& % & !?"47E9 % D ! && A #. !% & 34 &D% 477C % % $& &%' $! $% (%! & && BB%& $;/ A&%O!?%2$O&O/O9&'% A% $& BB?% & A&"$ D &!(&%%$ & &D&& % %& & A( & & && B& -- 13 of 15 - 2345624771,36238, (%! $%! & K A (&% & &%' % ;A;%9 & %&47E!'A!$%% $%% & & ' % K&% $% !%& 9 % &&B !%! 36 B!'% % 4771 A % $& $&!&D $% ($/% %%$ & G $ &! $& &9 B G & %& " 87E $ &! &%' $& &?& %&F(;%?% "377E & ' &!$&!$%& $%&;%?% &%' $ & D&$%?!9%"(!' $&?& % &F( $ A$$%&;%?%&(G?$&%' $ & D& $%?!9 / !A (&&% $ $ &!&%' (& ' &!&!% %9 , &47EB G!$%=% $%(!&& $&& & =& B B %%%B%%!$&& 9%%&:%%=&!% $ &9
369.
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of 15 - 2345624771,38238, 5-/4 -/ - / % 6 1
39.
!%%%%'D9 % 6
49.
(&$%& & !%&9
59.
S & ! " '%% %%& J77 B%9 " & &% $%& $& "B% &!$9
69.
"$%' %!&9
89.
B% $%& AS $'& B%% %% &% $%!& %%K& ! 57 =% : & B & $%: % D B!!% >.;] <%;BA CC776 @$%' %%&:%% & $D B%!&G%&9J4 B!!%% % DB!!%31 = 4778 > -@P ! % %% & A% & B & /$%'&$%&%?&%%%&& %P & K&% %! % D B!!% $% ' $& $% ' !&% A G & (%&9 64 -9 $%!& %%K& & $: $ %%& 'A!/$%' '&K&%= &"(' 9 ?%BB:% % , ^ %! & % _ $ B%$%!&%%K&&& B!G$%& AS"SBB B!!% % $%?%BB -- 15 of 15 --