Lexipedia

Décision

ATAS/63/2008

Décisions | Chambre des assurances sociales de la Cour de justice Cour de droit public

22 janvier 2008Français13 min

Source ge.ch

Considérants

46.

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

36.

&7"%(  %%& : "!91554 A!" 8 ("&&  &"   %&& ("&& 77'" 8( AA&  !9&7 !! <8 9&" %  %&!% 1554  7!&& (&&"6"&&&>%!&8&#("'&A&6 ;&#%%&% (# "% <A 8# ' <!&7 I' 8("";" 345H&155  !9&76 * J(C!8&&!&%&F&& - !!9,'&"9!8"7&&A "A&C!!9 A"6?K@  %  <7  !9& &' <L  %&& ( 7>"&"%9%&&!!&  6 !!  -- 2 of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of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

456.

 " 4/ "!91552( ;&"(%%&6&&A&&" (&&& ("A&8 ! "& %&"&& %"# !&&  9""A (    %!&    (&6 4: 6 4    A" "R,' &" 4.;4.=.? @6

446.

 "  4. H& 1552 (++     (  "" ("%&%!&&" &#( !&" (, <F!7 >4!15526

416.

("  %&%" #  &7 # (&  " %&& %"%A  "%&!& 8& !&7 25!1/;155= #=5E6%%&"&""&9#( &7%/;& 155=6-& 8"8(" &&'  %&!C&9 8A& (B&7%&!&%&!&, # ( 8& (<  && %&6 , #  &  "    ' !96  !"  ,&,  8 ("  %& % %   %A !7!B! # =5E ;&&  % 8  %&"&!  !&& ( % &&%#8& C79 &%&6 -- 4 of 11 -    012340155/,=044,

426.

 25H&155=(" "%"' !  "'  !,&7&8(++    '&# ' % "  14;& 155=  %"  %&&   %!& %/;&155= 4G6  8& %  "'   &  "&" !% % ("  1/ %&!9155=6  - %""8"&& &"("&&77'" %A"' 1552?7!&& (&&"  @&8(('&%&'" %  >"'6 4=6 %%& 4='!9155=A!" 7& !9&79&"<8 %4../&(%&" &'  =5E % "!9 15526 * !"  ("&&  &"   %&& & && "&& %"" 8( (-  ! A&  %& % %"&8J&&7&(9&!& 8;('!& ""  !&& 1=!1551J6

436.

!"  *'!" "7 ?,%>*@&&"8    (- '& %  &9 %-<86   >  %%"  A(7!&& &'%&" &'<7"6 4/6 1.!155/( !!8"#("%;&  "C&! 877'& "&& &"(-&"&"!"'  % (C%& 44;&1552 !,&"&&!&6 4:6 (" %"&" % )&  *    &&"  %;&  "6

4.6

 "  4=! 155/ (   A!"  A (7!&  & (' &"6

156.

("%(&!"  ! &&;&"4:;155/ & & "6%%8;%   9A" "   (7!&&   & (' &" & B& ! 8  9!B!("&& &"(&%! A" >8AA& !&; (< %8('&%&" 76>'#&"7 8 &   I "&& %!& 8& #  "'& A&?%%& 1GA"'4..:&4=H&1554@8 I % & %  %A !7!B! # =5E?%%&  /;& 155=@ & A 8 (,<F!7 ('&  "" !! %&  %!&6A&"7!&' %%&"&9#& ( &7 AA&" # (&  " %&& %A  "%&!&  8& !&7 I8J%% %   %A !7!B! # =5E?K@ "&& " 8  %&"  !&& ( % &&%#8&C79 -- 5 of 11 -    012340155/,3044,   & %&J6  >' A 8   %%&  4= '!9155= 8"8J%& (!"&% % !%&J6 ("& >( & &&& #(& (&&> %4H&155=6

146.

"% 4/H&155/( %%";& 6

116.

"&"&!#("&7 "#;76   $#

46.

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

26.

"%"   A! & " %"' %    %"&  & '9?&635 @6 G6  &7 %&   %&  '   7" (' &"  (" (& &9!&! A" % " 4/ "!915526

-- 6 of 11 --

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

36.

&"%&"' &"(%&" 7&&%&%"!"%!&   7 " "&& ( A!&" 7"& (!   (  &?&6: 6 4   & G 6 4  @6 & "%&" %&"  7 && !& (!9 (%& %9&" 7 ("!<"  &' "89" 8 &   "&  && !& "& (&&&#&"%<-8!&&8(%&%>&&!& &! " %&&C79?&6/ @6 /6 %' 7" (' &"(!&&?;7(- @  9  !& 8 !"  "'&!&  (& %"& '&A6&T< !" &#%&;7!& ("&& &"&# 8 8!&%8&'&"(" &%9 &'6& "!" &&&""!& & % "&! 8 &'C  %&  9!& C7  ("? + 41=  134  6 G 44=  42G  6 1 44G  24G  6 2 45=4=: 64@6 *  %%  9 %%"&  %' %!& '9  %" ;    ! ?A6&634 &6 @;7(&%"% >7A!! &C! !>9;&'&!- %'88(&%'% -- 7 of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of 11 -    012340155/,.044, "'&"%("(& ( !,&#CC&&!!&   "&7 4=!155/6.6 (  '& % "  45;' 1555  # ("  & #  !,&6  ("&& A "   %%&    &  8 AC& (%&"  &' # =5E &  "& 8 (&'&" % "7> C" % (" #!,&!% "&&  %&" #  "&&  &"6 (& ( !,&"&"!&4/ "!915529  (C%& &8 !&# 6   %" "' %%&  4='!9155= 8"8("&& &" (""&&&& %8( A"(7!&& &6

456.

&'87("8&%&B&"'"!B!("&& &"(&%! A"8"8%&" 7& 9<7!&!%&&6  9 "&&% &8!" (&'&"C" %("#!,&!%&&#(% ('& (&%%  &F  ('7 !<  & %A&!&  %&" #  "&&  &"6% 7" (' &"A ' (%&"  &'? + 25;1553G205=@6%&&  &8  %&"  7  &! A"6 & (" ,&, " && &'&" > '15546 (&&&A %%(97&%("  !  !!7 %% 7""  &   ? + 41.  G32  6 G61 412  122  6 2 44/  1/:  6 19 G55 &  "A" &"@6"&8;7%&%A !%!&&'8 ("  A  (&! ,!B! %9  A %  "9&   %&" &'%"'&8&&&&" (A# %A& 7" ' &"? +453:3 61%6:/@6

446.

(" %% 8     &  ("&&!&"%!&8&#"'&A&&8 %& (!"&%% !%"&&6 ("!978!" A&# &"7  A&8( %& &!!&     8 (C! 8 & %&F& &&8(&%&&%""!&8(8A&%& !'6 +& &&8(-  &%&&!%&!&  (" (%&&&&&8&9;&' (&%&6AA& A&8("(&%%&'&"&' 42!1554%>(B& &'#A'1554 !!%"'%!"  -- 9 of 11 -    012340155/,45044, (C%8%%(C!%<-8,*A&&"&& ( "'&%&F&A'96 ;&8%<-&<"%"&"9 "%!8  !% !" !& & AA &  %&& &;  "!&&A6 416 (""A>"7!&%%&"&9%#A  &7#(& " %&&%"%A I/;&155=6  9  " >' 8    A& %%!& "&&  %& ("6 !&&!&!&'" !" &;&A8(("&  6 426 '& &&8( !& %&" &'  %&" 7(&&' % "!915526 %&, B&8;&"6 -- 10 of 11 -    012340155/,44044,   4#$3  #$ #     $ '   5 0

46.

"'96 ' 5 

16.

;&&6

26.

&"!!& 155A6#<7 &6 G6 A!  %&   8R %'& A!  &  %"& B&   "  25; >  &A& %>  9 A" "?*<UL<A83355G  @%' !&>  & %9A!"!&C&6:1 A" " 9A" " 4/; 155=? +@N !"!   &  8  !&A &!- %'&%&7& & ! &N & B&  "  9 A" " % ' %&  % ' "&8 C  &  (&6 G1  +6  %"& B& &  %>  %  &'8"!!!- %' '&B&;&#('6  7AA>   , V  " &   W  %A! %"&B&&&A"C%&8R#RAAA" " %7AA -- 11 of 11 --