Initiative «gegen Asylrechtsmissbrauch»

Popular vote of Nov 24, 2002 · Popular initiative · No. 491Volksinitiative «gegen Asylrechtsmissbrauch»

Social and societal policy: Asylum policy

The cantons accepted the proposal but the people rejected it, so it failed.

Yes 49.9 %1'119'342No 50.1 %1'123'550
13 cantons for11 cantons against
Turnout
47.9 %
Eligible voters
4'749'994
Blank ballots
23'749
Invalid ballots
9'941

The proposal

Type of proposal
Popular initiative, formulated draft
Department in charge
Federal Department of Justice and Police (FDJP)
Legislative period
46th legislative period

By canton

Pick a canton to see its municipalities.

AreaYesNoTurnout
Zurich50.6 %49.4 %52.7 %
Bern48.6 %51.4 %46.6 %
Lucerne48.1 %51.9 %52.5 %
Uri53.2 %46.8 %40.2 %
Schwyz61.6 %38.4 %54.5 %
Obwalden51.1 %48.9 %44.5 %
Nidwalden54.0 %46.0 %44.4 %
Glarus63.0 %37.0 %46.2 %
Zug48.9 %51.1 %53.4 %
Fribourg44.3 %55.7 %41.5 %
Solothurn55.6 %44.4 %49.6 %
Basel-Stadt43.0 %57.0 %52.3 %
Basel-Landschaft50.3 %49.7 %49.5 %
Schaffhausen51.6 %48.4 %65.9 %
Appenzell Ausserrhoden55.9 %44.1 %56.4 %
Appenzell Innerrhoden60.3 %39.7 %47.9 %
St. Gallen60.9 %39.1 %49.0 %
Graubünden51.5 %48.5 %38.9 %
Aargau58.0 %42.0 %42.6 %
Thurgau60.9 %39.1 %48.4 %
Ticino48.1 %51.9 %33.0 %
Vaud41.7 %58.3 %51.2 %
Valais42.3 %57.7 %36.5 %
Neuchâtel42.6 %57.4 %53.9 %
Geneva38.6 %61.4 %50.9 %
Jura39.7 %60.3 %40.3 %

Municipalities in Solothurn

AreaYesNoTurnout
Egerkingen59.9 %40.1 %46.6 %
Härkingen60.1 %39.9 %52.6 %
Kestenholz57.4 %42.6 %48.1 %
Neuendorf60.1 %39.9 %45.1 %
Niederbuchsiten61.9 %38.1 %48.9 %
Oberbuchsiten64.7 %35.3 %48.6 %
Oensingen64.1 %35.9 %47.8 %
Wolfwil54.5 %45.5 %45.7 %
Aedermannsdorf56.6 %43.4 %59.7 %
Balsthal59.9 %40.1 %50.3 %
Herbetswil61.0 %39.0 %53.5 %
Holderbank (SO)60.2 %39.8 %49.8 %
Laupersdorf61.9 %38.1 %54.0 %
Matzendorf54.8 %45.2 %59.7 %
Mümliswil-Ramiswil64.2 %35.8 %52.8 %
Welschenrohr-Gänsbrunnen63.6 %36.4 %59.7 %
Biezwil65.1 %34.9 %53.6 %
Lüterkofen-Ichertswil51.4 %48.6 %53.4 %
Messen51.4 %48.6 %47.8 %
Schnottwil48.4 %51.6 %48.4 %
Unterramsern45.3 %54.7 %58.6 %
Lüsslingen-Nennigkofen51.2 %48.8 %53.2 %
Buchegg47.4 %52.6 %51.8 %
Bättwil52.9 %47.1 %45.8 %
Büren (SO)61.9 %38.1 %50.9 %
Dornach38.9 %61.1 %50.3 %
Gempen48.3 %51.7 %45.9 %
Hochwald48.8 %51.2 %53.2 %
Hofstetten-Flüh48.2 %51.8 %45.7 %
Metzerlen-Mariastein49.1 %50.9 %60.8 %
Nuglar-St. Pantaleon55.1 %44.9 %44.1 %
Rodersdorf40.1 %59.9 %66.8 %
Seewen57.7 %42.3 %49.6 %
Witterswil45.2 %54.8 %49.5 %
Hauenstein-Ifenthal53.7 %46.3 %48.0 %
Kienberg57.5 %42.5 %44.2 %
Lostorf55.3 %44.7 %61.5 %
Niedergösgen64.3 %35.7 %53.7 %
Obergösgen63.1 %36.9 %47.5 %
Stüsslingen57.3 %42.7 %49.7 %
Trimbach59.4 %40.6 %46.1 %
Winznau58.3 %41.7 %50.5 %
Wisen (SO)35.9 %64.1 %49.4 %
Erlinsbach (SO)59.8 %40.2 %49.9 %
Aeschi (SO)51.6 %48.4 %48.3 %
Biberist54.4 %45.6 %54.3 %
Bolken47.2 %52.8 %48.0 %
Deitingen57.4 %42.6 %53.6 %
Derendingen57.4 %42.6 %44.7 %
Etziken54.6 %45.4 %50.7 %
Gerlafingen60.8 %39.2 %48.4 %
Horriwil53.2 %46.8 %53.9 %
Hüniken33.3 %66.7 %67.6 %
Kriegstetten57.5 %42.5 %51.1 %
Lohn-Ammannsegg47.2 %52.8 %53.2 %
Luterbach57.9 %42.1 %48.2 %
Obergerlafingen61.0 %39.0 %48.6 %
Recherswil54.5 %45.5 %55.2 %
Subingen59.3 %40.7 %45.0 %
Zuchwil57.5 %42.5 %46.3 %
Drei Höfe55.9 %44.1 %52.6 %
Balm bei Günsberg58.5 %41.5 %45.5 %
Bellach62.2 %37.8 %49.9 %
Bettlach60.1 %39.9 %44.5 %
Feldbrunnen-St. Niklaus49.1 %50.9 %61.5 %
Flumenthal64.6 %35.4 %43.0 %
Grenchen60.7 %39.3 %42.2 %
Günsberg63.9 %36.1 %53.3 %
Hubersdorf54.0 %46.0 %50.5 %
Kammersrohr11.1 %88.9 %57.6 %
Langendorf51.2 %48.8 %53.7 %
Lommiswil54.6 %45.4 %60.6 %
Oberdorf (SO)46.4 %53.6 %53.6 %
Riedholz52.0 %48.0 %64.3 %
Rüttenen49.5 %50.5 %59.3 %
Selzach65.3 %34.7 %47.2 %
Boningen58.5 %41.5 %42.1 %
Däniken66.3 %33.7 %50.7 %
Dulliken67.0 %33.0 %49.7 %
Eppenberg-Wöschnau67.0 %33.0 %44.4 %
Fulenbach57.2 %42.8 %47.8 %
Gretzenbach58.0 %42.0 %52.2 %
Gunzgen64.9 %35.1 %45.1 %
Hägendorf62.5 %37.5 %50.7 %
Kappel (SO)53.6 %46.4 %48.9 %
Olten49.6 %50.4 %49.0 %
Rickenbach (SO)66.2 %33.8 %50.3 %
Schönenwerd59.4 %40.6 %47.7 %
Starrkirch-Wil51.1 %48.9 %57.6 %
Walterswil (SO)68.2 %31.8 %42.6 %
Wangen bei Olten53.9 %46.1 %49.0 %
Solothurn42.0 %58.0 %50.6 %
Bärschwil70.5 %29.5 %49.5 %
Beinwil (SO)58.8 %41.2 %50.0 %
Breitenbach57.1 %42.9 %46.0 %
Büsserach62.2 %37.8 %46.9 %
Erschwil64.7 %35.3 %49.3 %
Fehren56.8 %43.2 %36.7 %
Grindel63.8 %36.2 %38.7 %
Himmelried46.4 %53.6 %47.5 %
Kleinlützel54.2 %45.8 %48.3 %
Meltingen55.9 %44.1 %47.5 %
Nunningen58.8 %41.2 %49.1 %
Zullwil63.4 %36.6 %48.8 %

In Parliament

Federal Council
No
Parliament
No

The councils vote on the federal decree, which recommends rejecting the initiative: a yes to the decree is a no to the initiative. The votes are counted here for and against the initiative.

Final vote, National Council

44 yes24.3 %137 no75.7 %

Final vote, Council of States

3 yes7.7 %36 no92.3 %

Recommendations

Recommend yes
SD, EDU, FPS, KVP, SVP, Lega
Recommend no
CVP, EVP, FDP, Grüne, LPS, PdA, SP, UCSPeconomiesuisse, Arbeitgeberverband, Gewerkschaftsbund, Travail.Suisse
No recommendation
Bauernverband, Gewerbeverband
Dissenting sections
Recommend yes: FDP AG, FDP SG, FDP TG

From launch to ballot

Launched by
Schweizerische Volkspartei
Valid signatures
107'438 of 100'000 required (107.4 %)
Invalid signatures
1'188
Collection time
538 of 550 days, 200 signatures a day
  1. May 11, 1999Pre-examination
  2. May 25, 1999Collection started
  3. Nov 13, 2000Submitted
  4. Nov 25, 2000Collection deadline
  5. Dec 4, 2000Declared valid
  6. Jun 15, 2001Federal Council message
  7. Mar 22, 2002Adopted by Parliament
  8. Sep 17, 2002Vote called
  9. Nov 24, 2002Popular vote
  10. Feb 11, 2003Result validated

Campaign

Party strength

Yes27.4 %No68.7 %Other3.9 %
Yes posters
1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8
No posters
1, 2, 3, 4, 5

On the same day

Documents

Sources: Swissvotes, Federal Chancellery, Curia Vista, Année politique suisse

Data: Swissvotes, the database of federal popular votes (Année Politique Suisse, University of Bern; CC BY 4.0), the Federal Statistical Office and the Parliamentary Services.